D&D 5E Which non-Realmsian setting for you?

[miniaturehoarder]

Dark Sun. Get the Psionics rules in for those who want them.

Mystara

The only choice.

I LOVE Mystara, but unless we are getting the Immortal rules, The 5E ruleset kinda has enough to get done what needs doing for a Mystara setting. And if we ARE getting Immortals rules, then it should be the last rules the edition sees. 3e's Epic level handbooks debacle need not be repeated.

 

[btmcrae]

Seeing as the last poll was so successful seeing the top two winners, Greyhawk and Planescape (hey, look who's ahead again!), being given the lion's share of WotC product support since, this poll ought to really make a difference too.

 

[Silverblade The Ench]

Vote Space Hamster, you fools!
*he says like Gandalf*

 

[nerfherder]

Yes! But the maps and elevations would need to match the originals.

Definitely - Geoff Wingate's

 

[Wednesday Boy]

I'd love to see FFG's Midnight.

With 5E's non-magical healing and lack of reliance on magic items, it might be a simple conversion already. Although I'm not sure how the heroic paths would fit into the 5E paradigm. Since they were in exchange for having no magic items, you could get away without using them. But they were really nifty.

 

[JWO]

I'm not really very familiar with Greyhawk (so apologies if I'm way off the mark here!) but I get the impression that it wouldn't really be different enough from Forgotten Realms for it to make any sense releasing it as a separate setting. Something like Dark sun or Eberron seem a lot more distinctive...

 

[havard]

Blackmoor
Mystara
Thunder Rift

 

[Knightfall]

Pelinore!

It's where I will be running my 5e campaign. I already started running an adventure from Imagine magazine - converting the Basic stats on the fly. I've also started doing some conversion, but real-life has interrupted.

And a major Pelinore release almost would be like releasing a brand new setting. It's not as well known. I'd never heard of it it until I read about it on The Piazza a few years ago.

 

[Rifter]

One choice I put down, was Mystara, but by Mystara, I am talking about the Red Steel area. The rest, I could care less about. Eberron, Spelljammer and Planescape would be my higest rated. I'd like to see more Darksun, but that and Mystara are definitely second tier for me.

 

[Beleriphon]

Saying PS:T is the best adventure for PS is a better way of putting it than saying one can't really grok PS without playing PS:T.

True enough, true enough.