-
Monstrous Menagerie II: Hordes & Heroes has a launch date! Mark your calendars for November 12th, 2024. 300+ more monsters for your D&D 2024, or Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition games, plus new horde rules and rules for heroic monsters who level up alongside you--whether they be allies, companions, or foes! Click here to follow on Kickstarter!
Converting Creatures from Other Campaign Settings
- Thread starter Shade
- Start date
Cleon
Legend
freyar
Extradimensional Explorer
Looks good. Environment, org, alignment look right. Advancement seems to be a special case. Maybe that advanced base constructs and base creatures can be used, but generally there is no advancement while the pilot is "driving" the juggernaut? Do we need a note on how to grant XP to PCs who are made into juggernauts?
Cleon
Legend
Yes, I think we ought to add something.
Say we have party of 5th-level characters piloting CR 10 Juggernauts. If they fight a CR 10 opponent and got the XP of a CR 10 vs. CR 10 encounter that'd be 3,000 XP, which is a lot of XP for the CR 5 pilots. If they used their own CR 5 instead of the Juggernaut's they'd get 9,000 XP!
It'd probably be "fairer" if the XP was adjusted to the pilots level, so they earned the 1,500 XP of a CR 5 vs. CR 5 encounter.
'Course that doesn't start to address the problem that it's more likely to be a mixed party, with one pilot in the juggernaut plus the rest of the PCs fighting normally at their regular CR.
freyar
Extradimensional Explorer
Yes, I'm really not sure what to do about the pilot. It would be easier if the pilot became a permanent juggernaut --- just use the LA ---, but that's not how these really work. We're going to have to think about this.
Shouldn't the Str (and Dex for that matter) modifiers depend on the base constructs we write later?
Shouldn't the Str (and Dex for that matter) modifiers depend on the base constructs we write later?
Cleon
Legend
It's certainly a tricky issue. It seems fairer to arrange things so the pilot gets roughly the same XPs as his or her non-juggernaut piloting companions get.
Yes they do. We can leave it for later if you prefer.
Cleon
Legend
Hmm... isn't that mechanically the same as the approach I proposed earlier that used a comparison of the CRs of the juggernaut and the pilot?
e.g. my proposal was along the lines of if a CR 11 Juggernaut fights a CR 10 opponent and its pilot happens to be CR 5 they earn XP as if they fought a CR 4 opponent.
In the above example, you could consider the Juggernaut as having a LA of +6 (CR 5 +6 = CR 11), so the CR 10 opponent grants XPs as if it were a CR 4 enemy (CR 10 -6 = CR 4).
However, the problem with Level Adjustment is that LA is in addition to a creature's levels/hit dice, so if the base construct is advanced in HD it will throw the numbers off. e.g. a wooden juggernaut would have LA +X regardless of whether it has 8 HD or 18 HD.
freyar
Extradimensional Explorer
Ughh, yes, I guess that's essentially the same. I don't think I quite followed your proposal earlier. Well, I think it's going to be fiddly and weird however we do it, so we can just take your suggestion.
Underbar: Pilot Advancement
When determining the XP earned by the pilot, determine an effective CR for each opponent the juggernaut fights. First, subtract the juggernaut's opponent's CR from the juggernaut's CR, then the effective CR is the sum of that difference and the pilot's CR. Then use the opponent's effective CR to determine the XP earned by a character of the pilot's level.
Underbar: Pilot Advancement
When determining the XP earned by the pilot, determine an effective CR for each opponent the juggernaut fights. First, subtract the juggernaut's opponent's CR from the juggernaut's CR, then the effective CR is the sum of that difference and the pilot's CR. Then use the opponent's effective CR to determine the XP earned by a character of the pilot's level.
