It is only enough if you don't actually want folks to know what a tension pool is.
-
Monstrous Menagerie II: Hordes & Heroes has a launch date! Mark your calendars for November 12th, 2024. 300+ more monsters for your D&D 2024, or Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition games, plus new horde rules and rules for heroic monsters who level up alongside you--whether they be allies, companions, or foes! Click here to follow on Kickstarter!
Rules for Immersion
- Thread starter GMMichael
- Start date
It is only enough if you don't actually want folks to know what a tension pool is.
Pedantic
Legend
Never call for a decision I can make as a player but my character couldn't make as a person in a situation. All action declarations should exclusively affect future events.
Those two design points settled, you should then strive to ensure as little space exists as possible between the character and player's motivations, (I like the mechanic @kenada described above) thus that playing the game effectively will mean making the same decisions from both perspectives.
Those two design points settled, you should then strive to ensure as little space exists as possible between the character and player's motivations, (I like the mechanic @kenada described above) thus that playing the game effectively will mean making the same decisions from both perspectives.
Last edited:
Thats fair. In my stupor I assumed I had did the link thingy.
The Angry GM’s Tension Pool: A Comprehensive, Definitive, Final Guide
Here it is. At long last. The definitive, comprehensive, actual, final Tension Pool rules. Well, final until I change them again.
theangrygm.com
Last edited:
Pedantic
Legend
I think that link is either invalid, or pointing to a site with access restrictions.
Oh lord.
The Angry GM’s Tension Pool: A Comprehensive, Definitive, Final Guide
Here it is. At long last. The definitive, comprehensive, actual, final Tension Pool rules. Well, final until I change them again.
theangrygm.com
RivetGeekWil
Lead developer Tribes in the Dark
I don't think mechanics or rules connect to "immersion". Immersion is highly individual, and it's not within the province of a game's rules to have any say in it.
Pedantic
Legend
You run into some trouble because immersion is poorly defined, and you will get people who have directly opposed preferences for what they'd consider "immersive," but I don't think you can remove the rules from the equation.
For example, I would say any decision I make as a player that my character can't make is necessarily less immersive. This means that a mechanic that say, lets me declare that there exists a helpful object in the nearby environment is harmful to my immersion. Having or not having a rule that enables that will absolutely affect me.
RivetGeekWil
Lead developer Tribes in the Dark
Harmful to your immersion. Such a rule does nothing to mine and may even enhance someone else's since it allows them to realize the world fully. This is why I specified that immersion is highly individual. What breaks immersion for you mechanically does not have the same effect on me. That indicates to me that the rules aren't the factor in breaking immersion, but how the individual player approaches the rules. It's why I won't ever write a game to "preserve" immersion.
Last edited:
Pedantic
Legend
I agree with you on the individuality, but not that there isn't implication for rules design. There isn't a thing I can do as a player to correct for how the rules function in a system that's creating unimmersive outcomes. It would be better if we could point to someone more descriptive and further upstream that's more clearly defined and more amenable to different expressions of preference than "immersion" when taking about this.
There's no escaping though that different rules choices or design goals will produce different levels of immersion in a given player.
What about memory? This is a thing my character can do (unless they have amnesia) and it pertains to past events. Closely related to memory is emotion: feelings about people, places etc as a result of things that have happened in the past.
I ask this question not just to quibble, but because it seems to me that many RPGers seem happy to immerse in a way that to me feels like being amnesiac and emotionless. For me, unless I am actually playing an emotionless amnesiac,
Similar Threads
