CreamCloud0
One day, I hope to actually play DnD.
i'm not quite sure how this is meant to relate to or distinguish anything between the differences of narrative or mechanics, perhaps some clarification after your coffee?DM: here is a thing to interact with.
PC: I would like to interact in the following way.
DM: I'm listening.
PC: (insert lengthy overly complicated Rube Goldberg/Scooby Doo plan here)
DM: That sounds pretty funny/creative and possibly something we will laugh about and a story to retell for years to come. And most importantly since it doesn't affect things in any long lasting or dramatic way i say, kudos to you fellow gamer.
So in short my answer to this line of thought is...The DM decides if mechanics are needed. Now obviously the rules lawyers and min maxers are going to adamantly explain how I am wrong...and that's ok. D&D is a big tent and there is room for all.
I could go into this thought process in more depth but its 7:15am and I could use some coffee.