They blew it.
I could hardly believe my eyes last night when Claire was talking to her mother in that park. I wanted to shout "Ask his name, ask his name, you idiot!" But of course she didn't. Then, while she listened in when Nathan was there, the conversation felt contrived to show Nathan as an uncaring father. Finally, as if that wasn't enough, Claire didn't manage to get a good look at Nathan while following him back to his car, and of course Nathan didn't manage to spot her after she threw that rock.
This reminds me of the first episodes, when the heroes would meet or be near each other for a few minutes and then go their own way, each blissfully unaware that they'd met someone like them. Only this time it felt utterly artificial, a railroading to insure Claire and Nathan didn't meet until another episode. Especially all that was needed was Claire simply asking for her father's name, something I believe any girl looking for her real father (not to mention one who is in as dire straits as Claire) would want to know.
The one bright spot in the episode was Sylar teaming up with an unknowing Suresh. Up until tonight, I wasn't sure if the actor playing Sylar was good or not (mainly, I admit, because I had first pictured Sylar as a bigger man). But this ep convinced me - I really enjoyed the expression of surprise when Suresh told him there are dozens of people with powers out there, and then Sylar's eagerness in going back with Suresh.
Next week has at least one part I'll be really interested in - it seems Claire finally confronts HRG with her knowledge that he's far more than a dedicated adoptive father.
Still, tonight was the first time I felt truly disappointed when a Heroes episode ended.
