• The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is coming! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!

AI is stealing writers’ words and jobs…

theCourier

Adventurer
Our job as compassionate humans isn't to stand in the way of innovation and progress.

Yes, a couple of artists may have to find another job. But enabling millions more to express themselves visually where we could not before is a huge benefit for humanity.

  • Monks lost their scribing job when the printing press came along. Too bad, but anyone saying "it's wild that anyone who cares about scribes of any kind would support the printing press" is... shortsighted at best.
  • Typesetters lost their jobs at newspaper printers when desktop publishing allowed the journalists to layout their own articles. Again, saying "it's wild that anyone who cares about typesetters would continue to subscribe to their newspaper" is the mindset of, frankly, a luddite.

Of course we care. We want these people to find another way of earning a living now that technology has come for their jobs. What we don't do, of course, is to try to but the genie back into the bottle. That's worse than useless.

But more importantly, that you and I can now create fantastical vistas and images just by typing text is WONDERFUL. It truly is an invention comparable to the printing press.

Yes, there are various issues that need to be ironed out. And yes, this will destroy a couple of careers. But don't go down the path where you try to cast shade at progression. There's no future for you there. Instead let's focus on the possibilities here :)
The vistas you create aren't wonderful, and only people who are enamored by AI think so. Mostly because they don't know any better, I'm assuming.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

overgeeked

B/X Known World
But more importantly, that you and I can now create fantastical vistas and images just by typing text is WONDERFUL. It truly is an invention comparable to the printing press.
I could do that before generative “AI.” So could millions of other people. They were known as artists. In the very near future they will no longer be able to leverage that skill to earn a living.

That’s not wonderful. Framing it as such is cruel. I hope you’re as glib and nonchalant when it’s your turn to be homeless and starve.
 

I wonder how many fairs/events AI art has won since '22
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smar...gence-art-wins-colorado-state-fair-180980703/

Taking a look at my own state fair's rules there's nothing saying that you can't enter AI art nor is there a separate category for it. On the other hand Texas' rules say No Digital Art period. California has a Digital Art category, but I wasn't able to find rules for it. Also wasn't bale to find rules for Colorado's state fair.
 

CapnZapp

Legend
The vistas you create aren't wonderful, and only people who are enamored by AI think so. Mostly because they don't know any better, I'm assuming.
Fair enough.

That still doesn't mean "AI is stealing writers’ words and jobs" is a useful take. You could say machines have "stolen" loads of jobs over the centuries, but so what.


AI text and image pattern recognition and generation is here to stay.
 

Zaukrie

New Publisher
Computers have been stealing our jobs for decades. We might not like it, but it is inevitable that people won't have anywhere near the kind of jobs we do in the future.
 

CapnZapp

Legend
I could do that before generative “AI.” So could millions of other people. They were known as artists. In the very near future they will no longer be able to leverage that skill to earn a living.

That’s not wonderful. Framing it as such is cruel. I hope you’re as glib and nonchalant when it’s your turn to be homeless and starve.
Each time something that previously could only be done by the few (millions) but now can be done by the many (billions) this is democratic progress.

I'm not trying to be cruel here. But this impending loss of jobs happens all the time and has happened lots of times before.
 

CapnZapp

Legend
Computers have been stealing our jobs for decades. We might not like it, but it is inevitable that people won't have anywhere near the kind of jobs we do in the future.
I find it much more worthwhile to see it the other way round.

Any job so menial repetitive or simplistic we could automate it liberates a human that could do something better.

There's no "stealing" involved. There's zero point being resentful towards machines, robots and computers.
 

Zaukrie

New Publisher
I find it much more worthwhile to see it the other way round.

Any job so menial repetitive or simplistic we could automate it liberates a human that could do something better.

There's no "stealing" involved. There's zero point being resentful towards machines, robots and computers.
Accountants and lawyers and finance people who love their job disagree. Most of this isn't simplistic anymore. Nor repetitive. I'm not resentful at all,

I was using the language of the OP. This idea that some work is beneath us and we need to be liberated from it is odd to me.... But that's not my point. My point is, computers and robots will do almost everything we do in the next century, and any job a human does is going to be very different than what we do today.
 



Remove ads

Top