D&D 5E Survivor Campaign Settings- Birthright Wins?

[Tectuktitlay]

Not voting, just immediately fixing the last post to have the numbers correct.

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 13
Dark Sun 12
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 13
Ravenloft 8
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

 

[MechaPilot]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 13
Dark Sun 9
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 13
Ravenloft 9
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

 

[77IM]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 13
Dark Sun 10 (+1)
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 13
Ravenloft 9
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 15 (-3)

Just doing my part to vote against an obscure setting and for a popular one.

...And I feel that Blackmoor should get a pass on being considered "too generic" since it was pretty much the first D&D setting. So in a way all that came after was copying it to some extent. If we're going to have one generic old-school fantasy setting on the list, why not go all the way back to the original?

 

[ThirdWizard]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 13
Dark Sun 10
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17 This one was way too high
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 14 Maybe I can save it for a little while longer...
Ravenloft 9
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 15

 

[doctorhook]

PS- Don't worry about not being the OP- you're doing great work, and saving me a lot of time. Once a thread is created, no one owns it.

No worries, my friend! I've sorta taken ownership of my own little aspect of this project, but I want to make sure you get credit where due too.

 

[Midknightsun]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 13
Dark Sun 10
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 11 Die Planescape and your "Our cosmos is your cosmos but bigger" complex.
Ravenloft 10 It's all about nostalgia, really.
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 15

 

[Zulgyan]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 10 have no idea what this is, sounds like a Dragonlance knock-off
Dark Sun 10
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 12
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 11
Ravenloft 10
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 16
best, most inspiring setting ever!

 

[Rod Staffwand]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 10
Dark Sun 10
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 13
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 8
Ravenloft 10
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 16

 

[psychophipps]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 10
Dark Sun 11 (+1) because life sucks. Wear a hat.
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 16
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 13
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 5 (-3) because I hated the art, it smacked far too strongly of trying for an "edgy WoD vibe" as a setting, and in trying to explain everything it was mediocre at everything.
Ravenloft 10
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 16

 

[gweinel]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 13
Council of Wyrms 10
Dark Sun 11 (+1) because life sucks. Wear a hat.
Dragon Fist 13
Ghostwalk 13
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 17
Mahasarpa 5
Mystara 13
Nentir Vale 11
Pelinore 14
Planescape 6
Ravenloft 10
Thunder Rift 18