[OT Movies] Top 5 Fantasy Films

[drowdude]

Why not just edit the first post with the new results?

 

[reapersaurus]

Harlequin - is there any criteria for it being a "Fantasy Film"?

For example, how is Braveheart a fantasy film?

 

[Harlequin]

Fantasy Film Criteria

Harlequin - is there any criteria for it being a "Fantasy Film"?

For example, how is Braveheart a fantasy film?

Good question reapersaurus

Critiria for Fantasy Film:

When i first started this Poll there were no criteria for what is a Fantasy Film and as you can see by all the varying types of movies posted peoples oppinion on what is a fantasy film and what is not is debatable...

How do you guys think i should tackle this issue?

Should i have a list of movies people can/should vote for?
and if so which films dont make the list?

If everyone can also check out the list on the first post and then let me know which films you dont think belong on this Poll from the movies below, please do.

Then at a later stage i will redo the Poll with a list of films people can vote for...


Harlequin

 

[Radagast]

I've read the boards for a while, thought I should finally post something. Flight of Dragons should definitely get more than an honorable mention. I'm surprised not more people have seen it.

 

[Harlequin]

BUMP

Just a BUMP

Tally has been updated as of February 1st 2002

Check it out on the first post and also post your Top 5
Fantasy Films if you havent done so already...

I will be removing the following films as i dont think they
are true Fantasy Films, if anyone disagrees just send me a post
and i will leave them on the list

Buckaroo Banzi
South Park: Bigger Longer Uncut
Kiki's Delivery Service
My Neighbor Totoro
Brazil
Heavy Metal
The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
Orphen
The Musketeer
Last of the Mohicans
Blade
Midsummer Night's Dream


Harlequin

 

[Harlequin]

BUMP

BUMP

Post your Top 5 Fantasy Movies if you havent done so...

I am also creating a website soon so i can keep an ongoing
tally there and also store votes and have yearly votes
to see if newer films can make their way onto the list...

I am sure Two Towers and Return of the King will be there
and maybe King Conan: Crown of Iron (which i am eagerly awaiting )...

Also others in the rumour mill, Crusader for one


Harlequin

 

[Mark]

Here are my top five in alphabetical order...

Excalibur
Fellowship of the Ring
Princess Bride
The 13th Warrior
Time Bandits

 

[Sir Osis of Liver]

OK, TOP FVE FANTASY FILMS FOR SIR OSIS ARE:

1) ARMY OF DARKNESS

2)CONAN THE BARBARIAN


3) LABRYNTH


4)FLIGHT OF DRAGONS

5)DRAGONSLAYER

honorable mentions: dark crystal, ninja scroll, LotR:FotR, vampire hunter, shrek, big trouble in little china, and record of the lodoss war.

 

[drowdude]

I will be updating the results of this Poll on this first message. good idea [drowdude]

 

[Harlequin]

Hi

BUMP for new updated Tally...

I have also now updated my website for this (just bored ) and if you want to check out the full list of Movies please do so with the link below...

http://www.geocities.com/mtgsale/Top5Fantasy.htm

There is also a message board to discuss any movies and also a section on upcoming new fantasy films (in the works) as well

Hope you like it...


Harlequin