Uller
Adventurer
Ridley's Cohort said:But it makes sense for Poison.
It could be argued that it makes sense for MOST spells to scale up with casters...Hold Person cast by a 10th level cleric should be harder to resist than one cast by a 3rd level one, right? We don't see a "Greater Hold Person"...well I guess ther is Hold Monster...but you get the point.
Of course, doing that would make spell casters all the more potent...so I wouldn't touch that one with a 10' pole(which, if I were a 1e character, I'd probably be carrying around with me for some strange reason...).