Recent content by Dioltach

  1. D

    Fantasy Stories That Don’t Romanticise the Past

    Guards! Guards! has a bit about wanting a king again instead of the Patrician, because of the old glory days. That idea gets pretty short shrift. As for other fantasy books that don't glorify the past: Shannara (where the past is truly grim), the Gentlemen Bastards (where there's not much...
  2. D

    Your top 5 movie trilogies of all time, and why?

    Does Conan the Barbarian/Conan the Destroyer/Red Sonja count?
  3. D

    Your top 5 movie trilogies of all time, and why?

    Blackadder II, Blackadder the Third, Blackadder Goes Forth.
  4. D

    Who's on your geek Mount Rushmore?

    Ged, Gandalf, Raistlin and Dallben.
  5. D

    Trailer A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms

    This looks good! The first Legends anthology that featured "The Hedge Knight" was published in 1998. Those years weigh heavily on my knees.
  6. D

    Fans of long series of big novels, sound off!

    It's the closest thing I've ever read to how my group plays D&D.
  7. D

    Hey look, there's a new Robin Hood show coming with Sean Bean as the Sheriff!

    Somewhere in Scotland there was a grave marked "Little John". I can't remember exactly when it was - somewhere I might have photocopy of the research I did at university - but I think it was in the late Middle Ages when they opened the grave. The skeleton was of someone with dwarfism, but...
  8. D

    Hey look, there's a new Robin Hood show coming with Sean Bean as the Sheriff!

    Maid Marian wasn't originally part of the Robin Hood stories. She comes from the tradition of French pastoral poetry about the shepherd Robin and the country lass Marian. When those works crossed over to England, "Robin" became confused with Robin from the Robin Hood legends, and so Robin Hood...
  9. D

    The Mandalorian & Grogu Trailer

    I like the AT-AT's crossing the mountain pass, but this trailer could easily be a collection of scenes from a new season of The Mandalorian. I'm still going to watch it, of course.
  10. D

    What Makes Something A "Classic"? EDIT: TO YOU

    Do I go back to it again and again? Do I still enjoy it all those times, for reasons other than nostalgia and/or comfort reading/watching/playing? Books like LotR, Jeeves & Wooster and Earthsea, movies like The Good, the Bad & the Ugly, Casablanca and the LotR trilogy, games like Planescape...
  11. D

    Star Wars: Starfighter

    I always thought the "Clone Wars" thing in the prequels was a huge miss. I'm pretty sure the mention in Ep. 4 was just a throw-away line: "You served my father during the Clone Wars." Sounds cool and mysterious, and in a few words implies a vast history. But here's the thing. The clones fought...
  12. D

    Spoilers What do people get wrong about Tolkien?

    Here's something else that most people don't know about JRR Tolkien: the J stands for "Jive".
  13. D

    Spoilers What do people get wrong about Tolkien?

    Have you listened to the audiobooks of LotR as read by Andy Serkis? He brings the dialogue to life.
  14. D

    Violence and (Geek) Entertainment

    I recently read one of the new Conan books, and was struck by something similar. Conan takes beating after beating, but in between each he miraculously heals. He starts each phase of the fight as fresh as a daisy. It annoyed me, because one thing I enjoy about sword & sorcery is the grittiness...
  15. D

    Today I learned +

    I bet the people on that overpass were glad it happened when it did, and not a few more metres along.
Top