Recent content by Celebrim

The same way a Hulking Hurler is capable of throwing a hapless victim to the moon I'd imagine - by abusing and staking multiplying effects that were published in multiple official sources without editorial oversight because moving fast wasn't considered an abusable effect. Go look around the...

I think the rules show why the conceit of the story doesn't work so well in a magical setting, as well as the sheer size of the earth no longer boggles the mind of the average modern person so the original story doesn't work so well for the modern reader. As an obvious loophole, I could summon...

Yes. If the "inputs" of the rules include things that exist outside of the fiction, that is they are in the meta about the fiction but not in the simulated reality, then that rule doesn't simulate something. "Rule of Cool" is an example of a rule that almost certainly isn't simulating...

Good for you, but I am saying based on stories that I've heard that DMs do play "Gotcha! Muahahahahaha!" and do not inform players in advance. No, I don't think this player was fully informed in advance. In general, not knowing everything about the outcome as a player is to be expected. The...

As fantasy heartbreakers go, it's pretty well done - at least at the level of reading. It is a hodge podge of ideas stolen from other game systems ("Blades in the Dark" looms large as it seems to over almost all recent game designs) and it is interesting reading a fantasy heartbreaker that...

No. They just mean that they'd prefer you not fill up the thread with an argument about how simulation is a dysfunctional play style and Real Gamers don't play that way.

I'm aware of the history here. Among a dozen or more other books I've read Peterson's "Playing at the World", Fine's "Shared Fantasy" and Dunnigan's "The Complete Wargames Handbook". We can assume we are both very familiar with the history of games and the development of roleplaying games in...

I strongly suspect that sensors and fire control are the dominant factor in space warfare. Can you see them before they see you? Can you calculate a firing solution? Can you predict how they will try to evade? If you are doing the Yamato vs. Iowa comparison and you are focusing on shell...

I have been mostly a forever DM. This past year we've had a lot of life disruptions - new kids, sick relatives, players getting in that point in life where they are their kids taxi, work, etc. So the normal story based games I run that depend on everyone being able to show up have been...

Pendragon, Traveler, Dogs in the Vinyard, and Dread Arguments could be made for Twilight: 2000, Fiasco, Toon, and My Life with Master

Which is why I prefer games with strong sim attitude towards play, because the moment in the middle of a game when I must suddenly rules smith is to me one of the worst moments you can have as a GM. But I think that there is more to sim attitude than just "We should have a rule for everything"...

I went deep into this about 25 years ago doing tons of reading in the college library and downloading all the then latest simulation software, and what I discovered is that realistic galaxies are depressing. It crushed my belief (alongside working in a bioinformatics lab) that there was life...

Well, the point is definitely not to make realistic planets. My understanding is the planets are really only a few dozens of kilometers in diameter, but this is big enough and people's sense of scale limited enough (as to what they can imagine) that the planets will generally feel planet sized...

Or maybe I've been the forever GM most of my life hearing horror stories like this about the abuse players have had to endure at other tables. I've sat in on other tables or been in campaigns that sometimes lasted years, but I never had a DM as bad as the one described. If our profession was...

Simulation is what we are trying to achieve. Abstraction is the thing like assuming we can simulate an airplane well enough for these purposes as a rigid body with a single point mass because we aren't trying to actually make it fly and it won't be a danger to lives if it crashes but we will...