Worlds Largest Dungeon Holds 'Secret Doors' Contest

Screenshot 2025-04-11 at 12.26.16 PM.png

This coming weekend, The World's Largest Dungeon--first published in 2004--is launching a 'Secret Doors' contest. Participants are invited to contribute material containing encounters or mini-dungeons found behind the many secret doors in the dungeon. Winning contestants win a share of a $500+ cash prize and published as part of a Platinum Edition of the dungeon being crowdfunded in May (it already has over 8,000 followers, so it looks like it will do very well).

The contest is run by Portals to Adventure, and is open to amateur writers, which they define as people who have not held a full-time job creating roleplaying games.

A submission is made of up to 4,700 words, a map, an image, and a video. The submissions must be for D&D 5E.

7 winners will win 5% of the prize money ($25+), 1 wins 10% ($50+), and the final winner wins $50% ($250+). A further 10 finalists win no cash prize (but they do get a ribbon!) The prize money is generated by fan voters, who pay $1 per vote (with a minimum total of $500). And yes, you can vote for your own submissions, and you can pay for multiple votes (to a maximum of 10, which the site says is to prevent people from simply buying a victory). The prize money for the winners works out at about 5c/word for the winner, 1c/word for second place, and half-a-cent for the 3rd-10th places.

The contest opens on April 13th, and entries close on July 2nd. Fan voting then runs until July 17th.

Unfortunately, this is one of those contests where all submissions (even those which don't win anythng) become property of the publisher, and they retain the right to use or monetise the submissions with no payment to the author. While this competition structure is becoming less common, it does still pop up from time to time; and characterising publication of the work as a 'prize' rather than something which should be paid for can sit uncomfortably with many freelancers. It's far more common these days for publishers to retain the right to use the material (to protect themselves from later accusations of plagiarism) but to pay any writers whose content they actually do use.

"All submissions become the sole property of Producer and may be used in any manner, commercial or otherwise, including without limitation in the Program or any other Program, in any and all media and/or technologies now known or hereafter devised throughout the universe in perpetuity."

On a more positive front, the contest forbids AI-generated content, including text, images, and maps.

The upcoming Platinum Edition of The World's Largest Dungeon is an updated version compatible with D&D 5E. It launches on Backerkit on May 13th, and is over 1,500 pages in size, plus posyter maps, dice, and miniatures. It looks set to be a big one--perhaps a new million dollar club member?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I ran the original World's Largest Dungeon back in my 3e days and it remains one of my proudest campaigns ever. It was freaking fantastic. Warts and all.

Didn't know about this but, wow. Gonna be looking into this.
 

Seems pretty disrespectful for a production that's aiming for a big pay day publication, with a long established history in publication, to cheap out when it comes to paying writers for content. If you want to add outside writers' work into your publication, then pay them properly. Not even touching on the pay to vote system, which seems very problematic. This is a company, they should know better.
 

Sounded somewhat cool to look into until they wanted a video to go with the submission to post to YouTube and wanting me to get friends to vote for me and such like it is middle school. Gives it a feel more like a popularity contest over a search for good/interesting writing scenarios. I'll still check out the backer when it comes out to see if I want to purchase.
 

I'm wondering if the copyright of all the previous material isn't known which would lead to them needing replacement material? Or that they don't have full rights to the previous material per contracts?

Also, when did this company buy most of AEG's RPG line?
 

So the publisher is paying nothing for the work and using it to generate income.

They ask fans to submit ideas amd ask the fans to pay the prize money by paying to vote. Plus if more than 500 people vote they get the extra money? And they own all the ideas.

Naughty Word that Naughty Word

Hopefully no one falls for this begging thier friends to pay for votes thinking it will be thier big break into the RPG industry. The whole thing makes me feel icky.

Work for exposure but you have to pay us for a possible chance at that exposure.

That's scummy.
 

Yeah, I considered it for a second because I am trying to rebuild my freelance career after a few years away, but the pay scale is really out of whack. They should have done this as an open call with a standard rate (even if it was on the low end).
 

I ran the original World's Largest Dungeon back in my 3e days and it remains one of my proudest campaigns ever. It was freaking fantastic. Warts and all.
When this came out, I was playing in a local store. One of our players picked it up and decided to run it. It did not go well. I suppose in more capable hands it may have gone better, or even been fun, but I remember browsing it in the store and the writing/design seemed pretty generic from what I read. Also, IIRC there was quite a bit of empty rooms. While it is typical for most dungeons to leave room for the DM to develop but touting your product as the "Worlds Largest Dungeon" with that much empty space it would have been a letdown if I bought it. This certainly looks like an upgrade, the minis, look nice, and the AudioRPG is something I'll have to look into, but I suspect by the time this comes out, add shipping to the Backerkit cost of the product this will probably cost around $500.
 


When this came out, I was playing in a local store. One of our players picked it up and decided to run it. It did not go well. I suppose in more capable hands it may have gone better, or even been fun, but I remember browsing it in the store and the writing/design seemed pretty generic from what I read.
I've never heard of anyone who had a good experience with this dungeon, which very much seemed (and seems) like RPG shovelware.

The fact that people are competing for part of a $500 prize is ludicrous. No one should be submitting content for this. Your time is more valuable. Put your secret doors in a simple PDF (even just exporting it from Google Docs will work) and put it up on DriveThruRPG for $1. You'll almost certainly make more revenue and if your goal is to get your name and your work out there, you'll have more impact doing it on your own.
 

Related Articles

Remove ads

Remove ads

Top