What is the "Best. Ravenloft module. Ever?"

[reveal]

I want to run my group through a Ravenloft module. Having never run one, I am looking for advice. If you had only one Ravenloft module to run a group through, or play in, which one would it be?

 

[Harlock]

Ravenloft

 

[A'koss]

The original.



Cheers,

A'koss.

 

[Arnwyn]

I6 Ravenloft.

Oh, that's been said already (how 'bout that?).

I also liked "Ship of Horrors".

 

[Ruined]

Yeah, the original was pretty good. I also liked 'Adam's Wrath', but I'm a fan of the whole Frankenstein schtick...

If you haven't checked out the Kargatane website yet, you may want to. They're the official Ravenloft site, pretty much. They have reviews of most modules, which would probably be of interest to you.

 

[Mercule]

I6.

Barring that, I'd recommend "House of Strahd".

 

[Kid Charlemagne]

I'll second the Ship of Horrors recommendation - it's a nice, atmospheric, spooky adventure... I'll also second the original Ravenloft suggestion (or third, or fourth it). It's a classic, and one of the first to ever veer out from the simple dungeon crawl/linear quest paradigm.

 

[Ashrem Bayle]

Dark of the Moon was good.

 

[Marius Delphus]

I6 was updated and re-released (for 2nd Edition) as RM4? House of Strahd.

UPDATE: Also have to put in a recommendation for "Feast of Goblyns" and "The Evil Eye."

"Feast of Goblyns" can be downloaded for free. It's not a PDF package; the graphics and text are all separate. But it's free! (Actually, all the Grand Conjunction series modules are free downloads, but "Feast" is the one I liked best.)

"The Evil Eye" presented a very harrowing plot, which could lead to several alternative results depending on how the PCs deal with things.

Go to www.kargatane.com and look at all the reviews to see which adventure best suits your taste. (N.B., I'm not involved with the Kargatane folks, I just like 'em. )

 

[Savage Wombat]

My favorite has and always will be "Castles Forlorn", although it's not so much a module, as a campaign-in-a-box, y'ken.

It's brilliance even completely overshadows the fact that it would be an utter nightmare to run.