So, I went to the New York Rennaisance Faire this weekend:

krunchyfrogg

Explorer
First time I went in a few years.

The good:
  • They had this dude called the "chime master" or something playing a bunch of bells, which sounds corny, but looked and sounded really cool.
  • I bought my buddy a discounted ticket, so he bought me beer all day.
  • It really tired out my one year old, which meant she slept through the night.

The bad:
  • The joust sucked. It was about 10 minutes long, and it's sad to say, but they have a better show at Medieval Times.
  • They got rid of the torture chamber.
  • They got rid of the weapon tent (more on this later).
  • I saw way too many people dressed in the wrong costumes (more on this later).

Weapons Tent: The last time I went to a Ren Faire was about 3 or 4 years ago. The weapons tent was a place you paid like $2 or $3 to get into, and they showed you a bunch of neat weapons, and passed them around for people to get a feel for them. Well, last time I went, they passed a greatsword to a a bit slow (I don't want to offend anybody, but this is an important part of the story). I don't think he was expecting such a heavy object, and the sword came down in an arch and hit the guy putting on the show on the side of the head. Everybody was ok, but I'm sure the "weapons master" had a lump for a while.

Wrong Costumes: Okay, I get that some people really get into the Ren Faire and either have their own costumes, or they rent them there. My theory is, either go all out and play the part, or go in regular clothes and enjoy yourself. You can't really go wrong unless you go inbetween or get something out of a completely different genre. I also "get" the whole fantasy thing (pointy ears, faerie wings, ect.).

Anyway, I saw a lot of guys with swords, ladies with too much skin showing (who definitely should not be showing their skin), a few ladies with a lot of skin showing that looked good, and a couple of visitors from a far away land (Samurai and such). All good here. Then, the bad:
I saw a guy wearing a 12 year olds hallowe'en knight costume (plastic armor). I saw a guy wearing robes with vines all over himself (was he going for Swamp Thing, or a Druid?). I saw a kid walking around dressed as an eagle (it was a great costume, I was just confused). The one that takes the cake was a dude wearing all black, with a black hooded cloak and a sword slung across his back (we're good so far). He also had a lightsaber on his belt and a Darth Vader mask. I just don't get it.

Oh yeah, only one person, the whole day, took note of my Monty Python tee shirt with the French Knight saying "I FART IN YOUR GENERAL DIRECTION". Oh well, at least I got free beer.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



any of the above have to be better than the Pensacola Ren Fest. you have no idea how lame a Ren Fest can be until you attend one on the Redneck Riviera...
 


The New York Ren Faire *is* the Sterling Forest Ren Festival. So I'm not sure what you went to that long time ago.

NEW YORK RENAISSANCE FAIRE

There's a fairly big Ren Faire held annually in Sterling, NY, which is in "real" ;) Upstate NY, approximately an hour or so NW of Syracuse.

There's also the Sterling Forest, NY Ren Faire, which is downstate near Suffern - that's the one you linked to.

The names of the towns are slightly different, which causes much confusion every year.
 

Then, the bad:
I saw a guy wearing a 12 year olds hallowe'en knight costume (plastic armor)...

Oh yeah, only one person, the whole day, took note of my Monty Python tee shirt with the French Knight saying "I FART IN YOUR GENERAL DIRECTION". Oh well, at least I got free beer.

I'm trying to come up with a polite way of pointing out the cognitive dissonance of criticizing the quality of other people's costumes while also complaining that not enough people enjoyed a t-shirt with one of the most cliched medieval movie references ever. This is the best I could do.
 

Where is this? The one I went to was in Sterling Forest, Tuxedo, NY. I just want to be clear that these are two different places.

Did you spot a Starfleet Away Team? I heard that a group of friends were gonna go this year, in character, dressed in TNG Uniforms and their in character shtick was that they got transported to the wrong time to do some temporal anomaly.

Man, I havn't gone in two years, it's a great way to spend the day!
 
Last edited:

There's a fairly big Ren Faire held annually in Sterling, NY, which is in "real" ;) Upstate NY, approximately an hour or so NW of Syracuse.

There's also the Sterling Forest, NY Ren Faire, which is downstate near Suffern - that's the one you linked to.

The names of the towns are slightly different, which causes much confusion every year.
Exactly. I went to the NY Ren Faire years ago while visiting my Aunt in New Jersey. I have attneded the Sterling Renaissance Festival in Sterling New York (Northwest of Syracuse, near Lake Ontario) several times since. The Sterling Festival ended on August 15th, which is why I knew that was not the one the OP was referring to.

The thing that always struck me most about the Sterling Ren Festival was the way the cast stayed in character whenever they were out. I found at the NY Ren Faire and at King Richards in Massachusetts, that cast members sometimes dropped out of character when they were still out among the crowd, but no longer "on stage." Somehow having the cast members not in character killed some of the charm for me, despite all the people not in costume (including myself).
 

The thing that always struck me most about the Sterling Ren Festival was the way the cast stayed in character whenever they were out.

Whenever the royalty goes by, I always love dropping to one knee aand yelling "Long live the Queen!" Actors and patrons seem to love it equally, and once I got a whole group of people on one knee.
 

Trending content

Remove ads

Top