Quidam said:
Would you consider a girallon close enough in shape to a humanoid to allow items and weapons to be used? Speech? I don't think I'd allow speech, but the form has hands, stands upright, etc.
On a side note- anyone got a favorite 8HD creature to poly into?
I ran a game that included a level 10 druid and I gave him a rundown of some of his Wildshape choices. To my surprise, he wound up preferring the Dire Ape, even though it is a 5HD creature. Why?
Well, the main reason is that it has 10' reach, unlike most animals, can gesture and use body language much like a human, even though it can't speak, and because it has decent manual dexterity. I like to play these things conservatively, so I would not have let him wield all sorts of weapons designed for human-proportioned hands, but I saw no reason not to let him use a large greatclub.
Since you're talking Polymorph, you're not restricted to animals, so the Girallon seems a great choice for the same basic reasons as the Dire Ape. I definitely would not allow speech. I would not allow all items and weapons to be used, but would consider each on a case by case basis. A Gorilla's hand, arms, and body is general is not proportioned the same way as a human's. Some weapons might be just as easily used, while others might call for a -2 to -4 penalty to hit, and others be unusable.
Don't forget that having multiple arms does not automatically let you use them to full capacity with Polymorph or Wildshape.