Personally I didn't see much wrong with their *old* game.
What I'd like to see in a new mini game from them? Well, for starters a re-release of all models that were done for Chainmail, considering the game stores in Edmonton are quite possibly the most incompitent behemoths in the world, and refuse to get any of the final chainmail line in, even in small quantity, so having access to those figures would be nice.
I'd like to also see a full compatability with D&D in what models are made, but I think that's a given, since they did it with CM
I'd like to see the same quality of miniatures. If they go to that gooey tid-bit-creations crap that Mage Knight does, and start blobbing out these horrible little malformed, bent models made out of the same damn material that is used to do flooring in someones kitchen, I'm not touching that line with the longest pole in hades. Metals, I would like. If it's *got* to be plastic (which cannot hold the same detail), then do a hard plastic like the ones that GW does on sprues. Even a mix would be wonderful. Main heroes and creatures in metals, and rank and files in hard quality plastics.
Another thing I personally hope they do is NOT offer only pre-painted miniatures. Sure, It would be cool for them to release pre-painted miniatures, but as long as they also offer *Un-painted* versions of the exact same models. I'm a painter and hobbyist first and foremost, and a game player far second, and I'd rather not spend hour upon bloody hour trying to scour some terrible, tacky, shiny plastic enamel crap off of miniatures before I try to paint them myself.
I still have a painful feeling in my stomach that they will try and sneak in a Mage Knight clone, and that will mean I'll have to get 'official' D&D style miniatures from Reaper, or Rackham, because I refuse to buy hundreds of boxes of 'collectable' miniatures that bend more than a gum eraser on a hot day.
But those are just my personal wishes for the new line.