I'll be headed to New York City tomorrow (going to see The Producers) and my fiancee and I will have some time to kill... The closer to the Broadway area, the better...
I agree. I am from NYC originally. Compleat Strategist is the store to go to. It is down the block from the Empire State Bldg. Walk along 33rd street and cross 5th avenue heading away from the Empire State Building. It is about 5 stores down 33rd on the left. The storefront is pretty small and it is inset a bit from the street so it is a bit hard to spot at first look. (Spot DC 15)