DriveThruRPG's New AI-Content Filter

Full AI is prohibited, but partial AI is allowed.

Screenshot 2024-10-29 at 10.37.11 AM.png


DriveThruRPG, the largest online platform for the sale of TTRPG PDFs and print-on-demand titles, has added a new browsing option which allows customers to filter out AI-generated content.

By default AI content is set as viewable. The new setting allows you to choose between Handcrafted (no AI involved), Contains AI-Generated Content (part of the product is AI), and Creation Method Not Chosen By Publisher. The filter is found in the user account settings under Additional Preferences.

DTRPG's AI-Generated Content Policy (as of July 2023) requires sellers to indicate whether AI was used in the product, and will not accept "standalone artwork products that utilize AI-generated tools to make content." Additionally they will not accept "commercial content primarily written by AI language generators." However, titles partially created by AI are permitted.

Where a community content program (such as DMs Guild, Storyteller's Vault, Cypher System Creator, and so on), the AI policy is set by the publisher who owns the program.

Many TTRPG publishers, including Wizards of the Coast (although WotC's policy seem at odds with CEO Chris Cock's own statements), EN Publishing, Kobold Press, and more, have declared AI policies which exclude the use of AI art or text in their own products. WotC's previous communications director Greg Tito cited WotC's stance on AI as "..one of the major reasons I left. People above me just didn't understand that basic concept."

On the flip side, many artists are being accused on social media of using AI when they haven't, with people using any imperfection in an art piece as evidence of AI creation.

creation.png
 

log in or register to remove this ad




Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
This is a breath of fresh air, but I feel like "Creation Method Not Chosen By Publisher" might just allow people to side-step this.

Still, if it even reduces the amount of AI I see on DriveThru I'm happy.
I assume it’s because there are tens of thousands of pre-existing products on the site which were uploaded before the AI flag option was added to the upload process.
 

Bedrockgames

I post in the voice of Christopher Walken
This is a breath of fresh air, but I feel like "Creation Method Not Chosen By Publisher" might just allow people to side-step this.

Still, if it even reduces the amount of AI I see on DriveThru I'm happy.

To Morrus' point, there are a lot of books that were published before AI was a big thing that likely haven't been updated. You have to go in an individually change each product. I just did most of mine but have a small line that I still need to get to this week. My catalog isn't huge, but still it is a step by step process. I can imagine if someone has dozens or hundreds of books, it could be a bit for them to get to all of them.

Just another observation, when you put a book up on Drivethru, the option to select the creation method is not super obvious. It is mixed in with the pull down tags for things like genre. I imagine a lot of people might not be aware of the filter and may not see the button for it

I suppose another thing is the language. The term handcrafted made me think twice before selecting it (because to me it implies no digital elements). I hear a term like hand crafted and my brain imagines someone using no digital tools, working with ink, pencils, paper and paint. A lot of artists work in digital format and it took a bit for me to be confident this was strictly about AI. I think it would honestly be better if the category were just "No AI used in creation" (or something similarly clear)
 



Rabulias

the Incomparably Shrewd and Clever
I assume it’s because there are tens of thousands of pre-existing products on the site which were uploaded before the AI flag option was added to the upload process.
My thoughts exactly. Heck, there are many products there that predate generative AI itself.
 


Remove ads

Remove ads

Top