That's not the bit I'm talking about.
That's the bit I'm talking about. The repeated failed attempts to solve the puzzle itself. You list three attempts to solve the puzzle plus "a bit of back and forth" before getting to a roll. I can imagine how frustrating that is for the player, I've been...
Examples like this make me rethink letting players roll to solve puzzles. Maybe something like three strikes then roll. Or steal the Idea roll from Call of Cthulhu. If you're properly stuck make a roll. The story moves forward regardless, but on a failure you get a nasty surprise while on a...
Organic discussion or no, 2013 was the tail end of 4E where WotC published what…one D&D book vs pre-pandemic 5E. That’s like “organically” comparing your quadriplegic cousin’s skill at basketball to Michael Jordan’s.
I have threads on the topic if people want to stop derailing this thread.
Modules: Made to Read vs Made to Run?
https://www.enworld.org/threads/best-practices-for-easy-to-run-modules.716252/
Finished Philip K. Dick’s Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep. I took it slow. A chapter or two a day while reading other stuff.
The idea of the story came from Dick reading about psychopaths and empathy. It really shows.
Despite having read it multiple times already, the empathy theme really...