This is my dream project. I've jotted down so many different mechanics to try and capture the feel of those games, but nothing has ever materialized. And even if it did, I realize there is no way my game would ever be marketable.
Speaking of which, I picked up Rick Martinez's latest book, Salsa Daddy, and loving it. Packed with recipes for mashed, blended, chopped, and cooked salsas. I've made at least half a dozen an so far all have been tasty. Would recommend!
I own both BECMI and Rules Cyclopedia and prefer ACKS II because of the cleaner layout, updated rules (including AD&D material), and the extensive campaign rules (building and running).
Also having hardbound books chock-full of kick-ass, full-color art is worth the price as well:
@Desdichado...
Oh, another touch I really liked was a section on when to "fudge the dice"; quite the blasphemous topic in the OSR! 😮😄
But I couldn't agree more, it was all in the spirit of saving time and moving things along if nothing of note would come from the result, like the last creature getting dropped...
I have an entire closet full of them. I've been fascinated/obsessed with them since I received my first copy of Heroquest as a kid.
My absolute favorite is Quest for the Pixel which I talked about in my thread here. Just a straight up, dice chucking dungeon crawler. Almost every dungeon crawler...
It absolutely can and has lots of optional rules you can use to make that happen. For instance, there are separate treasure tables for Classic campaigns (standard OSR) or Heroic campaigns (High-Fantasy).
ACKS II is an improvement in just about every way IMO.
While ACKS was a cleverly houseruled...
From the bottom of my heart, I love the Trolls, but they absolutely are the worst when it comes to editing.
I thought they were going to put more effort in this front once they started reprinting everything for Reforged, but doesn't seem like it unfortunately.