-
Monstrous Menagerie II: Hordes & Heroes has a launch date! Mark your calendars for November 12th, 2024. 300+ more monsters for your D&D 2024, or Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition games, plus new horde rules and rules for heroic monsters who level up alongside you--whether they be allies, companions, or foes! Click here to follow on Kickstarter!
D&D 3E/3.5 Mallet of luck
- Thread starter abe ray
- Start date
Yaarel
🇮🇱He-Mage
In 5e?
Xanathars has advice for how player characters can create magic items. Generally the cost is the same as whatever the cost is. Upgrades cost the new minus the earlier.
No spells needed.
A Fighter can make a magic item, which makes sense if one thinks of certain katana makers and so on.
However as DM, I dont like buying or selling magic. So I would require ingredients that are symbolically relevant that may or may not be hard to find.
As DM, I also want skill checks like Arcana or Nature and especially Tool checks like Smith if making a magic sword.
Generally, I would make a sidequest out of putting the proposed magic item together, along with skill/tool checks to determine success.
And of course, the DM needs to agree the level and thematics of the item are appropriate.
As DM, what makes magic feel magic, is having a personal relationship with the magic item. The magic item will a have part of the personality of its creator within it. The ability to attune a magic items depends on whether the player is carrying out an intention, if any, of the original creator. This mostly for special items, tho, that are powerful and thematic. Common items can be routine and mainly for the sake of convenience.
Xanathars has advice for how player characters can create magic items. Generally the cost is the same as whatever the cost is. Upgrades cost the new minus the earlier.
No spells needed.
A Fighter can make a magic item, which makes sense if one thinks of certain katana makers and so on.
However as DM, I dont like buying or selling magic. So I would require ingredients that are symbolically relevant that may or may not be hard to find.
As DM, I also want skill checks like Arcana or Nature and especially Tool checks like Smith if making a magic sword.
Generally, I would make a sidequest out of putting the proposed magic item together, along with skill/tool checks to determine success.
And of course, the DM needs to agree the level and thematics of the item are appropriate.
As DM, what makes magic feel magic, is having a personal relationship with the magic item. The magic item will a have part of the personality of its creator within it. The ability to attune a magic items depends on whether the player is carrying out an intention, if any, of the original creator. This mostly for special items, tho, that are powerful and thematic. Common items can be routine and mainly for the sake of convenience.
Last edited:
Yaarel
🇮🇱He-Mage
It has been a while since I played 3e. But actually my approach was not so different.
I didnt care about money. I made the magic item a special sidequest to research and put the magic item together. I encouraged the player to create a unique magic item, and think about ways to make it flavorful and special. I used skill checks to determine success.
At that time, it didnt occur to me that non-mage characters can make magic items too. But now I would let them.
abe ray
Explorer
Thanks
Whizbang Dustyboots
Gnometown Hero
Edgar Ironpelt
Adventurer
A "Mallet of Luck" really ought to work on Constructs too ("Percussive maintenance!")
If introducing it into one of my games:
Spells required: Both magic weapon and magic fang
Cost: 4,000 gp
If introducing it into one of my games:
Spells required: Both magic weapon and magic fang
Cost: 4,000 gp
