Search results

Which I was told several times in this thread. Goose meet gander

If you have that much lore for the silly elf game to justify killing a PC tiefling, I don't know what to tell you.

Your premise begins with the notion that somehow everyone knows the PCs are guilty. Apparently the PCs were dumb enough to do it in plain sight, leave witnesses, and announced their names as they did it. And everyone around saw the burned wreckage and knew it wasn't orc raiders or the cow...

Aka you will what I want and how I want. Thank you for proving my intuition correct. I wouldn't touch your game with a 11 foot pole. I've played in games like yours and I know how it ends.

I assume the government also takes care of the powerful monsters and villains as well, making sure the community is safe and doesn't need adventurers. Or do they just sit around and monitor the player characters? Sometimes crime happens and no one gets punished. Villages burn and no one is held...

I mean, I tend not to have players who burn down villages but I also don't set up lynch mobs because they are an orc or tiefling or... Tabaxi...

Dang. I KNEW I smelled museum tourism! Burn down a village because they tried to lynch a fellow PC and suddenly 20th level archmages with gank you when you sleep. Teach those players to mess with my setting! It always starts with "I have a carefully considered vision of my world" and it ends...

Yeah, my love of strongly themed campaigns (I've done pirates, paranormal investigators, crime syndicate and will be starting a Western) can somewhat override limitations because the theme is fun. For example, the paranormal investigators had people play a dhampir, hexblood and reborn along with...

Correct. Which is one of the many reasons I gave up homebrewing for a rotating series of settings depending on the game. The Internet has made finding a game easier, buts it's not order a pizza easy. I live in the suburbs of a major metropolitan area and I don't see a large call for open...

The art of compromise is to.get other people to agree with you and feel good about it. I never got an actual answer to my question: if I DO give up my Tortle, what is in it for me? If you say "a seat at the table" that was part of the initial pitch, I have my seat thank you. So let's play a...

Ouch. I'm not a fan of one species games in general. If the DM was trying to do Vampire: that Dark Ages using 5e rules, i'd question why they are using D&D and not Storyteller. But if the DM was interested in augmenting the limited species with a larger selection of classes and such (things...

I kinda want to know how, if tortles are supposedly as rare and unknown as the DM says, the ranger specializing in Tortle hunting came from...

Yes. That said, I'm glad that rangers have moved from the wilder-nazi style of favored enemy that encouraged that kind of design. I don't like PvP, so anything that encourages interparty conflict is ok to go the way of the dodo.

So the players were mad his character was ineffective? I guess its true that its Rude to Suck at WoW, but that highlights a certain mentality. If, for example, the 4e play had rolled ability scores and rolled poorly (like, nothing above a 14) would it be fair to make him re-roll until he was...

That fine. I'm pretty sure your game would be too narrow and hemmed in for me anyway. I'd be a museum tourist allowed to look-but-don't-touch because anything that ruins your fun would get me booted.

Its actually ironic, I don't have a tortle PC idea. I was using it because it was the original example. That said, I am DYING to play dhampir bloodmage (wizard with the blood wizardly from Taldorei Reborn) for a while now, but the curse of being a Forever DM means the character sits in my ideas...

I always question this line of thinking. I used to run my own homebrew for a while and I can tell you with 100% certainty I did NOT flesh out my world to such a degree that I could not add new options (PC or monster) if I so chose. Why would you do so? You lock your world into a finite state so...

I think that's where the "compromise" framing falls apart. I am look for a compromise of "How can I play the character I want in a way that won't upset your world-building", which I have given several options from mutant to magical creation to super-rare species previously unknown to "came off a...

The question asked was "what is my motivation besides I want to". It doesn't matter why I want to. My motivation is neither sinister nor malevolent. The reason I wanted to play him was because the muses inspired that concept in my head. The question is what, if anything, can be done to...

Do I need to justify why I want to be a wizard instead of a fighter?. Do I need to justify why my character is an elf to play one? Because it interests me is sufficient enough motivation, unless you are going to force me to justify in writing why I made every decision on my character sheet...