Search results

How did the 5e vs 5.5e thread somehow randomly morph into the "Circus Troupe" thread about Setting Lore?

Point Buy is totally balanced, but the stats themselves are not. Depending on what class/subclass you're playing, there are always better stats than others

Oh I guess I thought we were just talking about people posting in this thread here, so I wasn't considering the original blog post itself. Even still though I don't think the blog post was particularly negative against people who like 5.5e, mostly just against the new rules themselves. I think...

I think it's more like they don't know the intricate details of either ruleset closely enough to notice the difference when their character sheet is changed while they aren't looking. Many players are like that, probably over half I'd estimate

I must be blind because I'm not seeing much negativity from either side here. Seems to me like pretty reasonable debate from both sides, all things considered with it being the internet and all

Yeah same here. The main complaint I've heard from real-life people outside internet forums is "barely anything changed why should I pay $50 for new books that are barely different", which is definitely a valid complaint but was easily addressed once one person shared the content on DnD Beyond...

You don't need to dump Wisdom to do that though. Evidence: far more players than I care to count!

Or maybe the new books are actually really good, and I just don't agree with someone whose products I previously liked (and still like). Different people have different opinions

Rolling stats is dumb and I would never do it. But yeah anyways dumping Intelligence is always the right answer unless you're a Wizard or Artificer then dump Strength (maaaybe Charisma if you want heavy armor and care about movement speed).

Both sets of 5e rules are much more superhero/epic fantasy than nitty gritty low fantasy, but I would agree that 2014 rules were more possible to run low powered characters. 2014 rules had a such wide range of unbalanced character power options, where the optimized 2014 PCs would blow away...

That's a really good quote! It is very true. For me this is a great description of why 2024 rules are so much better - because balanced gameplay was prioritized first and DMs have to then figure out the narratives for (or just ignore) how things make sense in their world. I can totally...

I do totally agree with this. Just like some people go overboard with verisimilitude at the expense of gameplay, on the opposite end of the spectrum you also don't want to go overboard with always saying yes to everything and removing any challenge from the game. I think we're just disagreeing...

I have to very strongly disagree with you that some sort of verisimilitude logic should ever get in the way of letting the players do a cool thing to help out an NPC they've taken a liking to. Fun >> fantasy game "realism", every time

The quest giver is an Adult Bronze Dragon in disguise, whose "capabilities go beyond what is presented here" (quote from the module). High level caster NPC already introduced

It seems like the module just says that Myla's wings are "badly injured", not that they're completely decapitated or anything. So I don't see why they couldn't just heal normally over a long period of time, or quickly with magic available to the party like Cure Wounds. Personally I'd say the...

Deryan's Helpful Homunculi is technically not listed as an Artificer spell but that is almost certainly an oversight by WotC seeing as how the Deryan NPC for whom the spell is named is an Artificer. That spell costs 100gp but cuts crafting time in half so you could get double the scrolls as...

Nah, it's properly rated as being pretty bad, but still playable and fun if you don't mind being less powerful. Portal Jump looks super fun, and Adventurer Atlas Positioning is bound to come up with some creative shenanigans, but Faerie Fire is just so weak with as easy as Advantage is...

Off the top of my head the big nerfs (in general order of priority) would be Divine Smite, Conjure Animals, Sharpshooter, GWM (overall buffed but nova damage nerfed), Wildshape (low levels only), Stunning Strike, Assassin surprise, Gloomstalker Dread Ambush. The only major nova damage buff in...

Artificer is definitely the most DM-dependent class, with the only possible exception of Rogue Thief subclass. In a campaign with enough crafting materials and unlimited downtime, having 1 Artificer per party is maybe the most powerful PC you could add to your party. In a campaign without...

Yeah totally agree but mostly this is a result of Zard trying to fill out the entire span with Best at S-Tier and Worst at D-Tier just because that's how Tier lists typically work. Really it ought to be the latter of what you wrote above with Sorcerer at S-Tier, Wizard at A-Tier, and the worst...