Search results

How can we say control spells are ruining 5E if we can't figure out what an unruined 5E looks like???

Let's take the time to show our gratitude towards Gygaxian Naturalism! Let's talk about how great it is and stuff. I'm sure glad we have it for one.

Gygaxian naturalism in action! May the best play style win!

So what's the next step? Are we gonna do a poll to decide which plot we're gonna use?

I do not. I simply want what is best for D&D. And we all know the quality of the players is the biggest factor in how well a D&D game does. And what produces quality players better then Gygaxian Naturalism??

Sorry but I believe that D&D should purge the weak from its ranks. If you lack sufficient tactics/system matery/fictional positioning then you deserve negative outcomes in your D&D game.

The obvious best comparison is to the Golden Girls

Do you think D&D can accommodate the both of you? If not, which one of you should be catered to and which one should be ignored??

So monsters were designed around four member parties; so your 13th level party was more like a 15th level party. And if your players were good at system optimization/tactical play, they're more like an 18th level party. And if they had a good amount of magic items on them, they would be more...

How many PCs are we designing for? A three person party is very different from a six person party.

Indeed. Which is why I advocate that Enworld should rule D&D instead of WOTC.

Can we have a fight against a dozen T-Rexes? I want a fight against a dozen T-Rexes.

D&D isn't Musk's game to conquer.

Who needs rituals when you got circle casting?? https://www.enworld.org/threads/circle-casting-is-gonna-break-a-lot-of-games.716050/

Want a fixed version of 5E? Go buy Level Up. Available on this very website!

but 5E is based off attrition?!? so if that barely works, then D&D barely works!?! oh well, good things most players couldn't care less about rules and how they work.

They don't ruin the game, they provide the D&D feeling that is so vital. If a player saved their control spell until the super dangerous monster showed up, then they deserve the chance to shut it down in one action. If a DM isn't wearing down a party through attrition, then they deserve to...

If I didn't want control spells to "ruin" the game, I'd go play 4th Edition!

For example... https://www.enworld.org/threads/why-enworld-should-liberate-d-d-from-hasbro.715803/