Recent content by Redneckomancer

Yeah I mean, if I'm playing at this table and we fight the Quantum Metagame Troll and I declare that I want to huck a fireball at it, and this fireball hucking is declared by the DM as Metagame Cheating, what.... happens? Assume it's my first strike in Metagame Cheating. Does the fireball still...

Wait, what? Are you normally supposed to divide the Xp between the party? I figured if it was a 100xp encounter, everyone just gets 100 XP?

Oh? What's his reputation? I've never heard of the guy?

Ah ok, I looked at page 261 (you got me to read the DMG, Snarf) and yeah it is the specific "Session Based Advancement" rules, not XP rules. Interesting! So you flat just level based on how many sessions you play. Though considering it says this I feel like we're back to square one 🙃

Well now I'm curious, this is still using the XP tables for level ups correct? Not milestones? How long then is an average combat supposed to last at the table?

So yeah my bulleted list is the best method i've found from that. If they don't see the dice they can't get hit with Forbidden Knowledge. Pathfinder 2 has a bunch of actions explicitly tagged as Secret even, so other games are already making it stock-standard instead of just DMG advice.

10,560 minutes, 10,560 moments oh dear, 10,560 minutes, How do you campaign, Campaign for a year? In combats, In Dex-saves, in rations, in chopped up goblins In hexes, in point crawls, in in-jokes, in even more combat In 10,560 minutes how do you measure a year in the life?

Ok cool. Correct me if I'm wrong, you want player advice on how you, as a player, can avoid the temptation of Forbidden Knowledge. Yes I'm being a bit cheeky, hopefully it lightens the mood. Well, again, assuming you want to avoid being a jerk and aren't acquiring Forbidden Knowledge for...

Rereading your Op I see you're more asking as a player than a DM, so when I do play, which isn't often, I roll (heh) with it. I rolled a nat one on this diplomacy? Let me play that out. It's an opportunity for some good comedy, honestly. I rolled low on the stealth check? Well, I wait for the Dm...

I guess I just disagree that metagaming is the problem there. Again, the problem is "adversarial mindset", the vector is metagaming. You can ban metagaming but that does nothing to disabuse the adversarial mindset. Also, just, my life experience has been mostly that metagaming just happens and...

Sorry, I'm still in therapy for my 2010 edition war PTSD :LOL:

By good faith I mean "not intentionally ruining the game for everyone else". If any metagaming at all ruins the game for you, and they know that, then yeah they're playing in bad faith. I also just think never metagaming is kind of an impossible standard and as a DM I just let it go if you...

Combat as War, Combat as Sport, Combat as Spectacle, Combat as Puzzle, Combat as Narrative, Combat as Genre Convention, Combat as Obstacle, Combat as Display, Combat as Performance, Combat as Story, Combat as Heroes, Combat as Anti-Heroes, Combat as Villain, Combat as Filler, Combat as...

This exactly. If a player is playing the game in good faith it shouldn't matter if they're metagaming or not. If you spoil the movie we're watching, it doesn't matter if you've seen the movie before or not, your specific behavior has ruined the experience. Also, specifically to RPGs, it's...

This whole video game analogy is kinda bunk from the start because, unless you're doing an old school con tournament, D&D isn't a 1 vs all competitive game? Maybe use Overcooked! or World of Warcraft raids or something. Also 'metagaming is an unfair advantage'. Unfair for who, advantage against...