• The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is LIVE! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!

Recent content by timbannock

  1. timbannock

    Grade the Silhouette System

    I played a bit of HG 1e and 2e, and a bunch of Tribe 8, both 1e and the 2e/SilCore version. The systems in both were a bloated mess. They read fine, but once we dove in there was just too many attributes, too many skills, and too much modifier fiddly-ness going on for a system that's meant to...
  2. timbannock

    SmiteWorks Hires D&D Beyond Founder as Chief Development Officer of Fantasy Grounds

    Oh there will be. Seems like VTTs are where all the money is in TTRPGs right now, and I doubt that will change significantly in a few years. In fact, I'd argue this news, Roll20's buying spree, and Hasbro dumping millions into DDB and its forthcoming VTT suggest we're in the next phase of what...
  3. timbannock

    Are TTRPGs Even a "Good" Hobby?

    It certainly embiggens the pool greatly, and with Discord and other ways to curate your gaming social circle, it's fantastic. That said, I don't know if it's just me, but any session past 2.5-3 hours is painful. This really limits the amount of mechanically complex stuff I can jam into a...
  4. timbannock

    Are TTRPGs Even a "Good" Hobby?

    Tactical 5E is just PHB, Kobold Press' Tome of Heroes, some of the mods in the DMG, and Flee Mortals as your primary monster book. Forge of Foes and The Monsters Know will be your other resources for encounter design, but I think the above books would be your full library.
  5. timbannock

    D&D Movie/TV Paramount+ Will Not Proceed with Dungeons & Dragons Live-Action TV Show

    Agree with all of this, but mostly just wanted to reply in order to say how shocked I am with how little they were working with! A team of 35 to get that degree of quality is absolutely insane. Even a mid-tier SFX-heavy American movie has easily over 3x that many people on slightly fewer total...
  6. timbannock

    D&D Movie/TV Paramount+ Will Not Proceed with Dungeons & Dragons Live-Action TV Show

    Exactly this. Some of the most consistently good, nuanced and believable acting I've seen has been in short-form horror movies over on YouTube and Shudder by people with like 75 credits that are all "Guy In Convenience Store #3". On top of that, there are plenty of name actors that will...
  7. timbannock

    Are TTRPGs Even a "Good" Hobby?

    Along those lines, even if it's not your bag I strongly recommend looking at Shadowdark and The Monster Overhaul. Both are very different, but one thing both do better than most products is give you so many useful resources for building stuff very quickly and/or on the fly. My preferred game is...
  8. timbannock

    Are TTRPGs Even a "Good" Hobby?

    Life is tough and it's short, so do what brings you joy. Learning to be more firm about various aspects, not playing certain games even if it means playing with different players or self-exclusion of people you like, playing in less-than-ideal venues (loud stores or looking at a VTT on your...
  9. timbannock

    Looking for Fantasy Atlas

    Thanks for checking, but nope! The animal-people and animal-mounts were all a bit more alien and not easily identifiable as to what animal they were exactly a version of. It was weird and bordering on grimdark, but not quite grimdark.
  10. timbannock

    Good stronghold rules?

    Going in a completely different direction, if you want the "social stuff" but without the "bean-counting stuff" I highly recommend looking for a system that is very lightweight. Maybe not "as lightweight as possible" but perhaps very close. The reason is that the impact these sorts of things...
  11. timbannock

    Looking for Fantasy Atlas

    I've been searching for days since I saw this thread and haven't found it because I can't remember the name, so I'll post here and hopefully someone will swoop and save me from continuing to rack my brain. There are tons of artists that release art books of world-building, so that's a great...
  12. timbannock

    D&D General Greyhawk to Faerun and Beyond: A Multiversal D&D Lore Book Is Coming This Fall

    I only recently ever got a look at those books because I was thinking of shoehorning them into a Seas of Vodari campaign I was running; I was basically adding any island-set D&D adventure that I could find into it. And I gotta say that while I ultimately passed on them for a variety of reasons...
  13. timbannock

    D&D General Greyhawk to Faerun and Beyond: A Multiversal D&D Lore Book Is Coming This Fall

    Just a wild guess here, but I suspect some of this is due to "cool factor." I think the folks in charge of D&D want to push out stuff that is extremely, visually part of the "D&D brand" and that doesn't really get a lot of love elsewhere. Both Spelljammer and Planescape got these special sort of...
Top