Recent content by MwaO

The quote.

You might want to get find sources that are not contradicting easily verifiable facts.

Even if that were true, that's comparing apples and oranges. Total revenue is what counts and DDI was a very large amount of total revenue.

According to multiple designers who worked at WotC, it outsold 3e. The issue wasn't that it did poorly. The issue was that it was expected to be a $50 million/year revenue game by Hasbro, they thought they were going to have a working virtual game table, and therefore would be able to charge...

That kind of scene is described as a bad skill challenge in DMG too. Point being, if you have a bad skill challenge to deal with due to an adventure or DM, the point isn't to punish the players, the point is to let the players figure out a way to deal with it. If you have a good skill challenge...

Yeah, a big problem with skill challenges, which even in DMG are designed to be fast and loose and reward creativity, was that a significant chunk of the adventures didn't understand that in year one. As an easy example, in a skill challenge, you can use any skill you want — roll hard DC and...

Yeah that's my group too. I DM'd 4e a lot when it was in person, but feel distinctly uncomfortable doing it online for reasons. But we have 3 DMs in our group and they switch off.

There are two different things that monsters/enemies/etc...are expected to do: Fulfill a combat role Do things in non-combat that are interesting and make sense. A simple example of this is the enemy wizard. Is an enemy wizard going to last 20 rounds? No. So don't give the Wizard 20 possible...

The 4e discord usually, if someone offers to DM a campaign, fills within a small number of hours.

Thanks!

You've seen this list? All the 4e CharOp handbooks and I generally update my own handbooks over time, though much more rarely now

Put Giant's Grasp onto the list — Monk 7 power — the impact isn't in the attack power, it is in what the move power does — it isn't forced movement, so you grab someone, run them past your allies with melee basic attacks

Updated the Encounter 7 Giant's Grasp to Sky Blue with hints of Gold — the movement action is "You move up to your speed. If you are grabbing a creature, the creature moves with you." i.e. the creature is not force moving, they're just moving, so they provoke...

I think Witch is slightly superior to the other Wizard classes if the goal is to play a fun, generalist Wizard. You get probably the best E1, you lose a cantrip, ritual casting(which is marginal — scrolls are expensive in theory until they're not) and a usually marginal class feature, you gain a...

Or you could have played the adventures or looked at Rogue's Gallery that made it quite clear that Gygax was an extremely Monty Haul DM with PCs with crazy high stats who railed against those who were even more Monty Haul and pcs with higher stats than his table's PCs. There's a Ring of Air...